Caglianone gets into the triple-digits on the mound and sits in the upper-90s dipping into the mid-90s at times, but he's of more interest as a hitter for now. That could change with improved control and a more efficient fastball shape. He's not quite as athletic as Ohtani, who is an elite athlete, but he does have 70-grade bat speed with a 90th EV of 113.3 mph. He hit 64% of his batted balls over 95 mph and might have the best contact quality in the class. He's aggressive and has one of the worst chase rates in the country, but his bat-to-ball skills are average and the 70-grade power drives his production.

Shelton has incredible feel for pull side loft and the power numbers showed up in the box scores. He doesn't have great raw power, but more importanly he gets all of it to play in games because of the swing path and early connection, he's pull-heavy with all of his hard-hits being put into the air. His bat-to-ball skills are below-average and his swing decisions are too. Since he's making his decisions so early to get to the pull side juice, he'll have the occasionally swing. He's physical at 6-foot and has an average arm, he's a 45-grade defender at third and probably won't stick long-term. He's a better fit at second, and the power production will keep him in a lineup regardless of the glove.

Coppola was a highly regarded prep prospect out of New Jersey in 2021, but ended up at Florida but has struggled with injuries throughout his collegiate career. He’s a massive lefty who works in the 91-93 range, but likely has more in the tank. He moves well and has flashed a solid slider, as well as an interesting change-up profile. 2024 was rough for him, and the track record is limited, but the traits are still strong.

Cyr was productive in two years at Miami, and will aim to do the same in his first year at Florida in 2025. While he’s played shortstop in college, he lacks the arm strength to stick at the spot long-term and will likely move to 2B where he’ll play above-average defense. The power here is below average, with a 107 mph max EV, and he’s got some whiff to his game that’ll likely show up more frequently moving into pro ball.

Coppola was getting first round buzz in '21 and looked good in his college debut as a freshman but he's yet to throw since. He's massive, and still could get into the mid-90s one day. He was 89-94 in his debut and flashed a sweeping slider at 78-81. He's very much an unknown for now, but could be a top-2 round guy if he picks up where he left off before getting shoulder surgery.

Shelton’s hit tool is a problem for me. He chased >30%, whiffed >30%, and whiffed in-zone >20%. Players with that profile don’t usually make it far in professional baseball without top of the scale defense, which is not the case here. There’s bat speed and plus raw power, but if it’s usable is still to be decided. There’s prospect pedigree here, and the bull case is that if his hit to was below average (45-grade) it becomes attractive as a senior sign, but I’m not sold on that being a possibility.

Robertson was a plus athlete out of high school but missed his freshman year with injury and had his fair share of struggles in his sophomore season. He's a plus runner and above-average defender in CF but lacks the decision making and approach to make up for the lack of thump and power.