Silva’s shortstop defense is plus and a carrying tool in a vacuum. He’s got great instincts and lateral quickness, but the arm is average. I have the hit tool graded as above-average, he rarely whiffs (13.6% in-zone, 20.5% overall) and makes quality swing decisions. The power ticked up in 2024, 110.3 mph Max EV, but he’s struggled to get to it. There’s a world in which you have an above-average offensive producer and true everyday SS, which is a great profile to have in your organization.